As you know, this scope just wasn't working for Gene. Turns out I was needing a compact scope and had a Bushy Legend I didn't need, so Gene and I did a trade. Don't tell Gene, but I think I got the better end of the deal ;-)!
First, this is a surprisingly compact scope for the power level, it's actually a tad shorter than the BSA 4X AO I have on my Gamo. The eye relief is also quite long, Burris designed this for use on short action magnum powder rifles, so they gave it plenty of eye relief, even on full mag it's almost 4" and at low power it's about 5". I could actually see this as being a problem with some rifles, but for the AA S200 I've got it on, it's perfect.
The other surprise was 1/8" clicks. Call me weird, but I happen to like 1/8" clicks, so that was a pleasant surprise. So all that's fine, but how does it work? Well, I'd have to say this is the best scope I've owned yet, period. And that's a bunch of different scopes over the last few years. The optics are crystal clear, and despite only having a 32 mm front objective, it's very bright. To test this, I actually shot it in my shop with most of the light out. I had trouble seeing the reticule, but no trouble seeing my target, even at full magnification. Edge to edge clarity is superb, and my eyes didn't detect any distortion. Clicks are accurate, tactile, audible, and easy to move without being the least bit sloppy. In fact, all the adjustments are very smooth, and only slightly stiff, which is to be expected from a brand new scope. One other surprising feature, the eyebell actually has a locknut on it, no "fast focus eyepiece" that never holds it's adjustment.
To sum it up, I've finally found a scope that I think is BETTER than my old Simmons 44 Mag, and for me, that's saying a lot. In fact, I may just sell the Simmons to get another one of these for my Cyclone, it's that good. Considering that it's a Burris and still under $200, this just shot to the top of my list as an answer for the "what scope should I buy?" posts. So if you're in the market for a "surprisingly" good scope, here it is. Later.
Dave