Randy,,,, in order to get a perfect fit You will end up having to refinish your stock. If you are willing to accept a less than perfectly flush fit,,Like on MANY guns,,, you can take the time to custom fit the Morgan pad to your gun. In that case I would recomend the black plastic one. Much more forgiving as far as asthetics goes. The aluminum one really needs IMO to be custom ground & polished. Just my 2 cents,,,,, Tim.