What distance are you shooting? Also, it may depend on what type of wood your are shooting. If a hardwood, that may as good as it gets. If a softwood like pine it should pass through. I just finished replacing a piston seal on a BC yesterday and the AG is shooting harder now than when new. However, I had to try several seals to find one that fit the compression chamber the best. Also, even though the gun has been de-burred, I carefully work the seal past the slots cut in the tube to avoid any possible damage to the seal.
After assembly, I flattened a soup can and taped it to a one gallon milk jug filled with water with another guart sized container behind that. At 45 ft, a CPHP passed through the flattened can, the milk jug, and the quart behind . Pellet found imbedded in the back stop. Before the water drained out, I shot several more times with the same results.
And it may not be just the seal. Could have some spring issues too.