John:
What did you do for this lube tune? How long ago did you do it?
Does it do the same thing with heavier pellets? Do you happen to have any CPH or Kodiaks around?
I would think that if it was dieseling, you'd know about it, as the report would be noticible and particualrly so in a confined space, but that kind of sounds like a mildish deisling condition, either from the wrong lube getting in the wrong place when you had it apart, or from a smallish cut in the piston seal when you reassembled it.
I'm just grapsing at straws here....
Another possiblity is that the erector mechanism in your scope is shot but I wouldn't expect it to print twenty shots high and the remaining right on if that were the case.
The reason why I am asking if you've got heavier pellets is that shooting them will kind of add more "backpressure" during compression, and thus cause more heat to be generated, and thus possibly force the seal to do it's thing and simultaneously help burn up any excess lube forward of the piston seal. Might help you troubleshoot the problem without tearing down the gun to do it........ Though if the seal is bad, you'll be tearing it down anyhow to fix it.
On another note.........
Sometimes I feel like an alien from another planet, because most folks who've shot Shadows tend to think they are really "hold sensitive" while the Shadows that I've shot have impressed me as being among the least worst offenders in that regard.
I've got an article on spring-piston shooting technique in the Photo Essay section of Uplandhunter.net that you might find helpful. I'm shooting my .177 R-9 in the photos but I shot my Shadow the same way, and shoot my wife's that way, and I got and still get very satisfactory results. It might work for you, too.
Oh, and as for cleaning. Everyone has their favorite bore cleaner for airguns it seems. Mine is Simple Green. The stuff works like a champ.
Blessings and Tight Groups,
-JP
http://www.uplandhunter.net