Hands down winner,, the 2250 pistol with the BSA scope. With 14.5" brl.,, B&A "Boss Valve", I get 20 full power shots, (600 fps 14.3 gr. CP,s) Plenty of power & very fast, quiet follow up shots!! If you go to the bottom of this page, then go to page 3,, scroll down to: "Got A Nutter One, (Very Graphic) you will see just how effective it is!!LOL!! Also,, on page 2: As Promised 2250 Season Premier!! C-o2 & Pumpers both have thier strong points & weaknesses, my C-O2 guns have more power unless its below about 50 deg.,, but thats another story!! Heck, for your $200 "budget",, you could order a custom 2250 like mine,, a 1377 pumper,,a steel breach& 22 cal. brl for it & have BOTH!!He He!! Trust me,,,,,, your gonna end up with both anyway,, I have seen this type of behavior before!! Have Fun Buddy!! Tim.